UNDER CONSTRUCTION;  4-12-2025.....




Virginian Pilot Article About Mattie Midgette's Store Being Listed 

in the 

National Register of Historic Places 

 December,  2004



VA PILOT ARTICLE:
 "Placed in the National Register of Historic Places, the First Colony Inn now stands on the coast at Nags Head as the sole surviving “beach-style” hotel, welcoming new generations to the old-fashioned pleasures of the 
Outer Banks." HERE 

FCI NRHP NOMINATION DR0022.pdf FCI NRHP NOMINATION DR0022.pdf
Size : 2232.631 Kb
Type : pdf
                 1972 photo of Mattie Midgette's Store
MMS NRHP Nomination DR0574.pdf MMS NRHP Nomination DR0574.pdf
Size : 1643.283 Kb
Type : pdf


Encouraging Historic Preservation:

 "Historic community buildings, neighborhoods,   and landscapes embody the intentions, 
 assumptions, and lives of those who built or   lived or worked in them. They have stories to   tell about what the community was and how 
 it became what it is, and that help us  
 understand who we are. 

 Preserving those stories can be an important 
 part of building a healthy community." Here


Official Certification of MMS 2004 Listing in NRHP



1972 photo of Mattie Midgette's Store










Mattie Midgette behind the counter in her 
Nags Head Grocery Store, ca. 1941







Mattie with her granddaughter Carmen 
in front of the store, ca. 1955




Jethro Midgette was a Commercial Dorey Fisherman.
He and his son Buddy set their nets along the beach front cottage line in front of Mattie's Store.









Mattie Midgette’s Store is a rare and compelling historic site. The property presents a singular example of the area's past form, traditions, and customs. Once a thriving grocery, seasonal tourist home, commercial and retail fishing operation, it served as the nucleus of the resort community. It evokes a palpable sense of "place" that embodies the Outer Banks of a century ago.

The old grocery also served as home to the Beachcomber Museum from 2003 through 2018. It contained a remarkable cache of seaside artifacts collected by Mattie’s eccentric daughter, Nellie Myrtle Pridgen. Like her mother, she was born in their family home in the tightly knit soundside community of Nags Head Woods.

A passionate beachcomber and early environmentalist, Nellie became a local legend as a fierce protector of the beach with a voracious appetite for information about the ocean and all things related to the natural world.


Beachcombing expert Richard LaMotte, who has visited the museum several times, had this to say about her collection in his 2015 book, "The Lure of Sea Glass":

“Inside a weary 1920s bungalow patiently sits the most extraordinary and diverse collection of seaside relics ever amassed by a beachcomber.” "The Lure of Sea Glass”



The Godfather of Sea Glass

Richard LaMotte Boosts the National Profile of Sea Glass

Few sea glass collectors DON'T recognize the name of Richard LaMotte. As the author of Pure Sea Glass: Discovering Nature's Vanishing Gems, LaMotte is a nationally recognized authority on sea glass. His book is now in its 5th printing, and he is routinely interviewed by national media including Coastal Living magazine.



This quote from a long time museum fan with connections to the area gives a look into the 
alure the story of Old Nags Head can hold....

 "Omg this is a treasure photo. Absolutely love this. But what gets me is the pic of Mattie and Nellie; 
I see an adorable older lady with her daughter who resonates high intelligence and style, hobbies and interests that are still relevant."

Photo of some of Nellie's Sea Glass by Chaz Winkler

Mattie Midgette's grocery was opened to the public for

30 days as the Nellie Myrtle Pridgen Beachcomber 

Museum for the first time in the Fall of 2003, during

the Centennial Celebration of the Wright Brothers' 

historic 1903 flight at "Kill Devil Hill". More than

a thousand people toured Mattie Midgette's Store

to learn about Mattie's parents' connection to

the history of Wright Brothers Monument. 


Since that time, thousands more people have 

visited  the museum to see the artifacts collected 

locally by Mattie's daughter, Nellie Myrtle Pridgen,

a legendary and now internationally recognized 

beachcomber and inspirational local icon.


Speaking about this site at the time of its listing in 

the  National Register of Historic Places in December, 

2004, preeminent Outer Banks Historian David Stick 

had this to say:


"Let’s put it this way, I would say next to Jockey’s 

Ridge and the Wright Brothers Memorial, it is the 

most historically significant place on the northern 

Outer Banks. It is an integral part of the 

Nags Head Cottage Row Historic District."


From the Virginian Pilot,  November 24, 2004.

Nellie Myrtle Pridgen  ~ ca. 1943
LINKS TO OTHER PAGES: